Creamy Peppercorn Sauce for Steak (2024)

This easy Peppercorn Sauce for Steak is a steakhouse favorite, blending simple ingredients to create a rich, creamy, and indulgent sauce with a kick. It’s the perfect way to transform your everyday steak into something extraordinary!

In a world of endless steakhouse-quality steak sauces, there’s one I struggle not to eat with a spoon: this peppercorn sauce for steak.

Besides its luxurious consistency and spicy bite, I love that this creamy steak sauce recipe is incredibly simple to put together. Peppercorns, brandy, cream, and beef broth are simmered with steak juices until you’re left with a rich sauce to drizzle over ribeye, filet mignon, or any cut you love. It adds a mouthwatering flavor with a subtly spicy kick!

Why you’ll love it

The black peppercorns in this black pepper steak sauce beautifully complement the beefy goodness of a perfectly cooked steak. Meanwhile, the brandy, beef broth, cream, and a touch of butter in the sauce create a creamy concoction with the perfect balance of richness and heat.

It’s sophisticated, well-balanced, and even stores well for a few days. Just take your black pepper sauce out of the fridge and pour it over your favorite proteins to instantly make your meal feel like a special occasion.

Ingredients needed

• Brandy, cognac, or marsala – All three of these options add an elegant complexity to the sauce and complement the natural flavors of the peppercorns. Note that most of the alcohol evaporates during cooking, meaning the sauce doesn’t taste boozy.
• Low-sodium beef broth – This is the second part of the base. You can use homemade broth or a high-quality store-bought broth.
• Heavy cream – A splash of cream is the secret to making the sauce feel luxurious, as it imparts a silky smooth mouthfeel.
• Peppercorns – I used coarsely crushed whole black peppercorns, but you can also use drained green peppercorns (from a jar).
• Butter – Adding a small amount of butter at the end of cooking (AKA “mounting” the sauce with butter) enhances the consistency and gives the sauce a silky finish.
• Worcestershire sauce
• Salt

How to make peppercorn sauce for steak

Are you serving this sauce with steak right away? Pan-sear your steak and save the pan juices in the skillet. They will help flavor the peppercorn sauce.

To make black peppercorn sauce, bring the brandy/cognac/marsala to a boil in the same skillet you used to cook the steaks. Boil until the liquid has reduced.

Add the beef stock and heat to a rapid simmer. When the liquid has reduced by half, lower the heat, add the cream and whole peppercorns, and simmer until thickened.

Take the pan off the heat and stir in the butter and Worcestershire sauce. Season with salt to taste, then enjoy!

Tips and tricks

• The black peppercorns give the sauce a slight kick. To tone this down, reduce the peppercorns to 1 to 2 teaspoons. For an extra kick, feel free to add more than 3 teaspoons.
• When pouring in the cream, do so gradually, and don’t stop stirring to prevent it from curdling.
• For a silky-smooth texture, consider straining out any coarse peppercorn bits from the sauce before serving.

Variations

• Use green peppercorns – Swap the black peppercorns for green peppercorns to give the sauce a milder, slightly fruity, and fresher flavor.
• Red wine reduction – Replace all or a portion of the brandy with a red wine reduction for a deeper, more robust flavor.
• Creamy Dijon – You can give the sauce a tangy kick by stirring in 1 to 2 teaspoons of Dijon mustard.
• Add mushrooms – The addition of sautéed mushrooms will complement the richness of the sauce and give it extra depth.
• Blue cheese – If you love blue cheese with steak, then try crumbling blue cheese into the sauce for a bold, tangy bite.
• Add fresh herbs – Give the sauce a fragrant, herbaceous touch with fresh thyme, rosemary, or tarragon.

Serving suggestions

It’s no secret that brandy peppercorn sauce was made for steak! But when choosing a steak to pair with it, opt for decadent and naturally beefy cuts, such as:

• Filet Mignon
• New York Strip
• Ribeye
• Porterhouse
• Sirloin
• Tenderloin

You also aren’t limited to serving peppercorn sauce with steak. Use the leftovers throughout the week to add an extra kick to your grilled or smoked chicken, pork tenderloin, or salmon. It’s also delicious drizzled over roasted veggies, like asparagus, cauliflower, and potatoes.

FAQs

Storing

Let leftover peppercorn sauce cool to room temperature before transferring it to an airtight container and storing it in the refrigerator for 3 to 4 days.

If you want to extend its shelf life, freeze the sauce in a freezer-safe container for up to 3 months. Before serving, thaw it in the refrigerator overnight and gently warm it on the stove while stirring to restore its creamy consistency.

More sauces for steak

• Red Wine Sauce
• Bearnaise Sauce
• Bordelaise Sauce
• Creamy Mushroom Sauce
• Peri Peri Sauce
• Chimichurri Sauce

​​​​Did you make this steak sauce?

If you loved this creamy peppercorn sauce for steak, I would appreciate it so much if you would leave a ⭐️star review⭐️! Also, be sure to snap a picture of your finished dish and share it with me on Instagram using the hashtag #platingsandpairings and tagging me @platingsandpairings.

For more great Platings & Pairings recipes, be sure to follow me on Pinterest, Facebook, YouTube, Twitter, and TikTok.